Cutting taxes creates jobs: wrong! History shows the exact opposite!

Get the Flash Player to see this content.

President Obama and Mitt Romney are talking to Americans about taxes. The President wants to raise taxes on those with taxable incomes over $250,000; Mitt Romney does not want to raise taxes on them. Mitt Romney is against raising taxes on those individuals with taxable incomes exceeding $250,000, arguing that it would have a negative impact on job creation. Barack Obama, however, argues that raising taxes on those earning $250,000 will not impact the middle class since taking care of the middle class will grow the economy.

So who is right? Republicans are always saying that taxes are too high and they are killing job creators. President Obama is saying, on the other hand, that, no, it is the middle class that creates demand and stimulates the economy, in turn creating jobs.

Today's Tax Rates Are Historically LowThe highest marginal tax rate in 1945 was 94%. Now it is at 35%. Similarly, the capital gains tax rate was at 25%; now it is at 15%. So the present tax rates are not at historic highs, as Republicans would lead you to believe, but rather at historic lows.

But do lower taxes create a booming economy? Do lower taxes help businesses grow their businesses and create jobs?

The Republicans have been saying for decades—and this has been unchallenged by the media and even by most Democrats—that if taxes are lowered, it grows the economy and creates jobs.  Examining a graph of the different top marginal tax rates from 1950 to the present time in relation to average real GDP growth, one can see that when those rates were at their lowest, real GDP growth were similarly at their lowest levels.  Average Annual Growth in Real GDP, 1950-2010In fact, at the current top marginal tax rate of 35%, real GDP growth has been at its lowest level in that time period.

However, when the top marginal tax rates were at their highest rates of 75% to 80%, the United States experienced its highest growth rates in terms of real GDP growth.  Although there are other factors involved in the level of GDP growth, the Republican contention that higher taxes would destroy our nation’s economy is not true when examining historical facts.

In fact, even when the tax rates were as high as 90%, the economy still boomed.  It was doing much better than when the rates were capped at 35%.  Now this graph shows the historical relation of tax rates to GDP, but how about their relation to jobs and employment.

Job Creation:  Average Annual Percent Growth in Total Payroll EmploymentAgain one sees a similar relationship.  The United States experienced its best years of job creation when the tax rates were at 75% to 80%.  And since the tax rate has been capped at 35%, the United States had the worst job creation rates:  in fact, the country has had a negative job creation rate:  the nation has been losing jobs; and this has been the only time the United States has lost jobs.

The United States has capped the highest marginal tax rate at 35% now for eleven years and it continues to lose jobs.  Tax cuts do not create jobs.  Often times they cost jobs.

When taxes are raised on the rich, history shows that our country does not lose jobs.  Quite the contrary, the nation experienced the highest amount of growth and the greatest increase in employment when the highest marginal tax rates were at their highest levels.

Consequently, the rich are not job creators.  And taxes on the rich does not have a negative impact on economic growth nor on the creation of jobs. 

The Barefoot Accountant
Accountants CPA Hartford, Connecticut, LLC
Certified Public Accountant
Certified QuickBooks ProAdvisor

About William Brighenti

William Brighenti is a Certified Public Accountant, Certified QuickBooks ProAdvisor, and Certified Business Valuation Analyst. Bill began his career in public accounting in 1979. Since then he has worked at various public accounting firms throughout Connecticut. Bill received a Master of Science in Professional Accounting degree from the University of Hartford, after attending the University of Connecticut and Central Connecticut State University for his Bachelor of Arts and Master of Arts degrees. He subsequently attended Purdue University for doctoral studies in Accounting and Quantitative Methods in Business. Bill has instructed graduate and undergraduate courses in Accounting, Auditing, and other subjects at the University of Hartford, Central Connecticut State University, Hartford State Technical College, and Purdue University. He also taught GMAT and CPA Exam Review Classes at the Stanley H. Kaplan Educational Center and at Person-Wolinsky, and is certified to teach trade-related subjects at Connecticut Vocational Technical Schools. His articles on tax and accounting have been published in several professional journals throughout the country as well as on several accounting websites. William was born and raised in New Britain, Connecticut, and served on the City's Board of Finance and Taxation as well as its City Plan Commission. In addition to the blog, Accounting and Taxes Simplified, Bill writes a blog, "The Barefoot Accountant", for the Accounting Web, a Sift Media publication.
This entry was posted in Accountants CPA Hartford, Articles and tagged , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , . Bookmark the permalink.

One Response to Cutting taxes creates jobs: wrong! History shows the exact opposite!

  1. Pingback: Historical Facts Debunk Myth that Tax Breaks for the Rich Create Jobs | The Barefoot Accountant on Accounting, QuickBooks, Taxes, Money, and Politics

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *